Lake Forest Park Planning Commission Discusses Cottage Housing, Development Regulations and Upcoming City Priorities

Image

Summary

The Lake Forest Park Planning Commission discussed opportunities to improve middle-housing regulations, with particular emphasis on cottage housing, while receiving updates on city finances, neighborhood retail, Sound Transit Stride 3, and upcoming planning department priorities.

Levy lid lift approved: Councilmember Josh Rosenau reported that voter approval of the levy lid lift gives the city greater budget flexibility and eliminates the need to pursue some previously considered budget reductions and potentially regressive utility fee increases.

Town Center business vacancies: Commissioners raised concerns about several businesses leaving Lake Forest Park Town Center and the potential impact on Third Place Commons. The former e-bike shop building has been leased to the Goddard School, while the former Rite Aid space remains vacant. The City Council is exploring ways to expand neighborhood retail opportunities and provide businesses with additional locations.

Cottage housing becomes a priority: A commission subgroup reviewing barriers to middle housing found that cottage housing appears to have support among both developers and residents. Commissioners identified unclear and outdated development-code definitions, including yard setbacks, undisturbed soil, and open-space requirements, as potential obstacles. The commission expressed interest in examining whether four cottage units could be permitted on qualifying properties and how other cities regulate cottage housing.

Limited staff resources: Commissioners raised concerns about the amount of technical research expected of volunteer members, emphasizing that professional planning staff should help evaluate code changes and provide comparisons with other jurisdictions. Staff acknowledged the city's limited capacity but indicated it could undertake targeted research when the commission provides specific questions and direction.

Planning director announces departure: Community Development Director Mark Hofman announced he will leave the city, citing workload, health concerns, and the need for improved work-life balance. Recruitment for his replacement is underway, with an initial candidate review scheduled for November 23 and a potential January start date.

Major planning projects ahead: Hofman identified three significant priorities for the coming years: middle-housing regulations, an overdue Critical Areas Ordinance update, and a Shoreline Master Program update. The city hopes to pursue state grant funding for the shoreline work, potentially beginning in 2028.

Next steps: The commission will continue its cottage-housing research, examine development regulations in other cities, and develop a work plan for the coming year. Commissioners also plan to hear from a local resident group researching cottage housing.


Deeper Dive:

The Lake Forest Park Planning Commission spent much of its recent meeting discussing ways to clarify the city’s middle-housing regulations, the potential for cottage housing, and several major planning projects facing the city in the coming years. Commissioners also heard an update on neighborhood retail, Sound Transit’s Stride 3 permitting process, and the upcoming departure of Community Development Director Mark Hofman.

Levy Approval Gives City More Budget Flexibility

Councilmember Josh Rosenau reported that voters had approved the city’s levy lid lift, giving the City Council more flexibility as it works to finalize the budget. Before the election results, the council had considered several contingency measures, including reductions to essential city services and increases to utility fees. Rosenau noted that raising utility fees would have been particularly difficult because those fees are regressive and disproportionately affect lower-income residents. He also reported on a productive community meeting concerning the culvert beneath NE 185th Street. Discussion focused on how the street might be redesigned when the culvert is replaced, with an emphasis on incorporating feedback from residents who live along the roadway.

Neighborhood Retail and Town Center Businesses

Rosenau provided an update on a City Council working group examining neighborhood retail opportunities. The effort is considering two general approaches: allowing more small-scale retail on residential properties and exploring opportunities to expand existing neighborhood commercial areas. The discussion comes amid concerns about businesses leaving the Lake Forest Park Town Center. Responding to a commissioner’s question, Rosenau said the Goddard School had signed a private agreement to lease the entire building previously occupied by the e-bike shop, which relocated after being required to vacate by the end of October. Regarding the former Rite Aid space, Rosenau said the property owner was looking for a quality tenant and might consider dividing the space into two units. He acknowledged that the city has limited control over private property owners’ leasing decisions. The council’s neighborhood retail work is intended, in part, to give businesses more options for locating in Lake Forest Park rather than relying on a limited number of existing commercial areas. Rosenau said the work could eventually be referred to the Planning Commission for further discussion, potentially sometime next year.

Stride 3 Permitting Moves to City Staff

Rosenau also discussed the permitting process for Sound Transit’s Stride 3 project. He said the City Council has largely completed its policy-level work related to the project. Under the existing framework, city staff will handle the remaining implementation and permitting responsibilities. Rosenau said the council is not expected to have a specific role in most subsequent decisions, with one potential exception involving a Sound Transit proposal for a parking garage larger than three acres. 

Cottage Housing Emerges as an Area of Interest

A Planning Commission subgroup consisting of John, Jean, and Yanni reported on its review of potential barriers to middle-housing development in Lake Forest Park.

The subgroup examined feedback from developers, the Leland report, the Middle Housing Toolkit, resident comments collected during the 2024 Comprehensive Plan update, and responses from a middle-housing community forum.

One concern raised by developers involved unclear or outdated definitions in the city's development code. Terms relating to front, rear, and side yards, street-side yards, undisturbed soil, and common or open space can create uncertainty when applying regulations to newer housing types.

Commissioners noted that some existing definitions were developed for traditional residential development and may not adequately address newer middle-housing configurations.

Although clarifying definitions might seem like a relatively simple code change, the subgroup cautioned that those definitions are used throughout the municipal code. Changes would require careful review to avoid unintended consequences elsewhere in the regulations.

Cottage housing received particular attention. Developers identified it as an attractive middle-housing option, and resident feedback also suggested it could fit Lake Forest Park's character.

Commissioners discussed whether the city should explore allowing additional cottage units on certain properties, potentially including four-unit configurations, and how permitted density might vary depending on lot size and zoning.

They also emphasized that any changes would need to account for the city's tree protections, critical areas, and other environmental requirements.

Commissioners acknowledged that while they can identify issues and suggest improvements, detailed code analysis will require professional staff time and expertise. Staff capacity is limited, and the city may need outside assistance to evaluate potential changes.

The subgroup has not made a formal recommendation. Members will continue meeting and bring more developed findings back to the full commission.

The commission also discussed the distinction between middle housing and genuinely affordable housing. While cottage housing may provide additional housing options, land and construction costs can still make the finished homes unaffordable for many residents.

<!-- EMBEDDED YOUTU.BE URL: https://youtu.be/3vBZucmaWSo?si=RxCywQZHC99UnMcJ -->
More News from Lake Forest Park
I'm interested
I disagree with this
This is unverified
Spam
Offensive